The courage to make a mess. And the courage to clean it up

Insight — 30 min read

The courage to make a mess.  And the courage to clean it up

Why creativity in B2B brand and campaigns needs freedom, constraint, rigor and positive friction

Creativity has two equally seductive myths: rigid process guarantees good work, or great creativity appears when all the rules are removed. Both can become excuses. Everyday courage is knowing when to disrupt the process—and when rigor demands that you hold the line.

There’s something slightly dishonest about most creative case studies. Not about the result. About the journey.

They nearly always work beautifully backwards. Studying the problem led to the insight. The insight became the strategy. The strategy inspired the creative idea, which became the work, which delivered the result.

Problem → Insight → Strategy → Creative → Success.

Everybody discovered exactly the right thing in exactly the right order.

That makes for a very slick presentation. It’s also rarely how the work actually happened.


Real projects misbehave

An idea is born before the strategy’s finished. Research contradicts the brief. The client says something in meeting three that everybody wishes they had said in meeting one. The first route dies. The second route exposes something wrong in the strategy. A customer uses the product in a way no one predicted. A constraint appears. Someone has a thought while everyone’s packing up. The team goes backwards, sideways, backwards again, and eventually forwards. Then the project succeeds.

So we draw a straight line through the mess. That’s understandable. Stories require coherence.

The danger comes when we start believing the story ourselves. We tidy creativity retrospectively. Then we take the tidy diagram and impose it as the process for the next project: insight must happen here, strategy there. Ideas may now commence. Concept selection on Thursday. Execution after Gate Four.

We turn the story of how the work happened into a rule for how work must happen. Then we wonder why the answers begin to look familiar.

This is one reason why Tim Harford’s Messy remains such an appealing argument.

Disruption can be productive

Unexpected people can bring new information. Interruptions can shake thinking out of habitual grooves. A constraint can force a different route. Reality rarely has the manners to arrive at the stage on the project plan labelled “Reality”.

Sometimes the brave thing is to let it in anyway. We know something today that we didn’t know yesterday. Change it. Go backwards. Rewrite the brief. Kill the idea. Bring another person in. Admit the original assumption was wrong. Let the customer ruin the hypothesis.

That requires everyday courage because organisations reward signs of progress. A neat process looks professional. Going backwards looks suspiciously like failure.

Yet if the purpose of a process is to help us arrive at a better answer, refusing to change when the evidence changes isn’t rigor. It’s theatre.

And creativity already has its own theatre.

There’s an equally seductive story at the other end of the argument.

Rules kill ideas. Process destroys creativity. Give talented people space. Let things happen. Don’t constrain the thinking. One more route. One more workshop. One more possibility. “Let’s not close it down yet.”

All wonderfully creative sentences. And potentially, also, all sophisticated ways of avoiding the much harder act of choosing.

This is where the argument gets interesting.

Sometimes, process is killing the work. Yet sometimes process is the thing stopping the work from becoming self-indulgent nonsense.

Sometimes, courage means opening things up. And sometimes courage means saying “Enough”.


Creativity and constraint have a more complicated relationship than our clichés allow

A 2022 meta-analysis covering 111 published and unpublished studies found an overall positive relationship between constraints and creative performance, while also finding considerable variation according to context and measurement. In other words, constraints aren’t automatically good, but neither is the assumption that they simply suffocate creativity supported by the broader evidence.

You’ll know this if you’ve ever faced a genuinely open creative brief. “Do anything” doesn’t always feel like freedom. Sometimes it feels like staring into space.

A useful constraint gives the mind something to push against.

Six seconds.

One audience.

Half the budget.

No new product.

It has to work without sound.

The technology can’t make that claim.

We need one thought, not seven.

It must be understood in two seconds.

The form creates the problem that creativity needs to solve. A sonnet has fourteen lines. That restriction didn’t stop Shakespeare being creative. It gave the language something to work against.

The same thing happens inside commercial creativity. The strategist saying: “That’s a lovely idea but it doesn’t solve this problem” may sound like they’re killing creativity. When they might actually be protecting it.

The client saying: “No, we can’t make that claim” may force the team into an idea it would never otherwise have found.

A budget cut can destroy possibility. But it can also pare back considerations to leave only what truly matters.

A deadline can result in dreadful work. But it can also end the comforting fiction that another fortnight of exploration will somehow make everybody certain.

There’s everyday courage in discipline

Killing the idea you personally love. Holding to the brief when everyone’s getting excited. Refusing to add another message. Choosing three routes rather than twelve.

Pausing. Evaluating. Deciding. Saying no to a senior person who wants to put the sentence back in. Saying no to a creative person who wants another week because they haven’t emotionally separated “more exploration” from “better work”.

This is why rigor isn’t creativity’s enemy.

Rigor is what makes creativity answerable to something beyond itself. The audience. The problem. The evidence. The commercial reality. The execution. The objective.

Without rigor, an idea can be interesting without being useful.

But rigor also has a failure mode. When every piece of learning has to fit the existing sequence, the process stops organising uncertainty and starts eliminating it. The creative act becomes a processing line. The same people. The same stages. The same workshop. The same template. The same answer with this year’s logo on it.

In marketing campaigns, where the objective is to stand out, engage and influence, familiarity and similarity are dangerous. Our brains are hard-wired to notice the novel and shortcut past the same old.

Perhaps there’s a better model.


Disciplined mess

John Boyd developed what became known as the OODA loop: Observe, Orient, Decide, Act.

It’s often reduced in management writing to a lesson about speed: loop faster than the competition.

But Boyd’s thinking is more useful than that. Orientation is central. We don’t simply observe neutral reality. We interpret it through experience, culture, knowledge, assumptions and the mental models we already possess. We decide. We act. Then reality answers back. That feedback changes what we observe and how we orient, and the cycle begins again.

That’s an excellent way to think about disciplined creativity. Not process versus chaos. But:

Observe. Orient. Decide. Act. Learn. Go again.

Each stage contains its own little act of courage.

Observe: can we notice the evidence that doesn’t fit what we hoped to see?

Orient: can we accept that our interpretation might be wrong?

Decide: can we stop exploring and actually choose?

Act: can we expose the idea to reality before we’re completely comfortable?

Loop: can we change the work when reality gives us an answer we don’t like?

That’s disciplined mess.

The process gives us movement. The loop gives reality permission to interrupt it. And suddenly The Case Study Lie looks even more interesting. The retrospective story says:

Research. Insight. Strategy. Idea. Result.

The lived project looks more like:

Observation. Wrong interpretation. Idea. Test. New information. Argument. Reorientation. Constraint. Dead idea. Old idea reconsidered. Decision. Action. Something unexpected. Loop again.

Then afterwards we draw the arrow.

Maybe that’s fine. The straight line is a storytelling device. The problem is when we mistake it for how discovery actually works. Which gives us a provocation not only for the industry but for our own team.

Stop only documenting the work. Start documenting the moments when the work changed. When did we learn something we didn’t know? Who disagreed? What assumption died? What constraint made the idea better? Where did the process protect us? Where did someone have to interrupt it? Which conversation changed what happened next?

Perhaps that awkward Wednesday when everyone thought the project had gone backwards will eventually turn out to be the most important part of the case study. We simply don’t know it yet.

Now let’s look at that other correction.


Not all mess is productive

Yes, some of it is discovery, but some mess is just mess. Bad briefing. Indecision. Lack of ownership. Ego. Politics. People refusing to kill work because they made it. People avoiding the discomfort of choosing.

The sophisticated creative culture has to tell the difference. Which brings us to positive friction.

We spend a great deal of business life removing friction. Frictionless journeys. Frictionless technology. Frictionless processes. But creativity without friction can become little more than politeness.

The strategist should occasionally make the creative uncomfortable. The creative should make the strategy uncomfortable. The client should introduce inconvenient commercial reality. Research should be allowed to destroy a beautiful assumption. Execution should expose what the concept deck conveniently ignored. Different disciplines should resist collapsing into one another.

That’s not dysfunctional conflict. It’s positive friction.

Nemeth’s research on authentic dissent is useful here too. The value appears not simply because somebody has been told to play devil’s advocate, but because different people genuinely hold different perspectives and therefore make the group consider the problem differently.

Real friction. Used productively.

Which means the goal is neither maximum control nor maximum freedom. It’s disciplined mess.

Enough structure to know what we’re trying to change. Enough freedom to discover that we may have defined it wrongly. Enough creativity to make an unexpected leap. Enough rigor to decide whether the leap is useful. Enough courage to change direction. Enough courage to stop changing direction. Enough friction to improve the answer. Not so much friction that nothing moves.

Sometimes the courageous acknowledgement is: “The process says we should move on, but reality has changed. Go back.”

Sometimes it’s: “We know enough. Decide.”


The difficult bit is knowing which moment you’re in

That’s why ultimately this isn’t an argument about process. It’s an argument about judgement.

The best creative cultures aren’t about limitless freedom. Or relentless control.

They move intelligently between opening and closing, exploring and choosing, disruption and discipline.

The case study can draw the straight line afterwards. The work itself needs permission to loop. Because a different conversation doesn’t always begin: “What else can we do?”. Sometimes it asks: “What are we actually trying to solve?”

And occasionally the most courageous word in a creative room isn’t yes.

It’s no.

Let's start a different
conversation.

What will courage feel like for your brand or campaign?

    or